ALISE/ProQuest Methodology Paper Competition

2024 Winners: Lois Wine and Shana Pribesh, Old Dominion University

Previous Winners

The purpose of this award is to stimulate communication on research methodologies at ALISE annual conferences.

The competition is open to all types of methodology. Papers must be limited to description and discussion of a research method or a technique associated with a particular research method. (For example, papers may address such areas as sampling, grounded theory, historical methods, or statistical methods.) Papers must explain the particular method/technique, including methodological implications for library and information science. Examples to illustrate its value can come from LIS-related published studies, proposed studies, and works in progress. Papers that stress findings are not eligible for this competition.

One winning paper will be selected. An honorarium of $500 will be awarded to the author(s). In cases of joint authorship, one honorarium will be awarded for the paper. Methodology papers prepared by joint authors are eligible for entry but at least one author must be a personal member of ALISE as of the award submission deadline date.

Sponsor

Award Criteria

• The candidate may not be a current member of the committee, nor may a current committee member nominate a candidate for the award.
• Unpublished papers, as well as papers published within the past 2 years, are eligible for submission. Manuscripts that have been submitted for consideration for publication as well as unpublished manuscripts posted to institutional repositories are also eligible for submission.
• Papers whose author or authors have won the award within the past five years are not eligible.
• Papers submitted to this competition can originate from a variety of different sources and applicants are encouraged to develop such papers from their research. Methodology papers completed in pursuit of master's and doctoral studies (e.g. thesis, seminars, dissertation, course work paper) are eligible, as are papers generated as a result of a research grant or other source of funding.
• The papers will be judged by the committee with the assistance of additional ALISE members in those cases where the methodology warrants. All reviewing is "blind." Methodology papers will be judged on the following criteria:
• Description of the method or technique.
• Explanation of methodological implications of the method/technique for LIS.
• Primary focus on the methodology itself, including its procedures, benefits, and implications.
• Innovativeness of the method. Innovativeness includes, but is not limited to, a novel research design, new application of an existing method, or the importation of an existing procedure to a new context.
• Examples of actual or potential applications to library and information science research or studies in related fields (i.e., from published studies, proposed studies, and work in progress).
• Appropriateness of the examples to the method/technique described.
• Clarity in the writing and in the paper's organization.

The committee reserves the right to select no winning paper if, in its judgment, none of the papers is considered satisfactory.

Submission Requirements

• Papers (excluding references, abstract, keywords, and supplemental materials) must not exceed 25 double-spaced pages and 6,000 words. In addition, papers should have one-inch margins and be in 12-point font.
• Two title pages must be sent: One with, and one without, author name(s) and institution. Both title pages must carry the name of the competition for which the paper is being submitted.

Submission Process

Submission Deadline

March 25, 2024

Winner Responsibilities

The winners of the awards are expected to present a summary of their papers at the ALISE Annual Conference.

Committee Membership

• The Committee consists of five ALISE Members, one of whom serves as Chair.
• Members are selected by the President-Elect and serve for two years and may be appointed to serve a second consecutive two-year term.
• The chair is selected by the President-Elect holds this position for one year, and may be appointed to serve a second consecutive one-year term.
• Committee members with a known or perceived conflict of interest must recuse themselves from discussing or judging any submission for which a known or perceived conflict exists.
• The Committee reports to the Past President.

Chair

Beth Patin, Syracuse University School of Information Studies

Members

Yi Bu, Peking University
Elliot Kuecker, University of North Carolina at Chapel
Susan Rathbun-Grubb, University of South Carolina
Gretchen Hoffman, Texas Woman's University

Board Liaison

Rong Tang, Simmons University

Previous Winners

2023 - Keren Dali, University of Denver & Deborah Charbonneau, Wayne State University: Using Hermeneutic Phenomenology and the Single Question Aimed at Inducting Narrative (SQUIN) in Disability Research

2022 - Nitzan Koren, David Weintrop, and Mega Subramaniam, University of Maryland: Using Design Based Implementation Research Method to Create Computational Thinking Assessment Tools for Youth Programs in Public Libraries

2021 - No award given

2020 - Vanessa Kitzie, Travis Wagner, A. Nick Vera and Jocelyn Pettigrew: Using the World Café Methodology to Support Community-centric Research and Practice in Library and Information Science.

2019 - Lynn Silipigni Connaway, Chris Cyr, Brittany Brannon, Peggy Gallagher, Erin Hood,  OCLC, for Speaking on the Record: Combining Interviews with Search Log Analysis in User Research

2018 - Lynne Bowker, University of Ottawa, for Corpus Linguistics: It's not just for linguists!

2017 - Sarah Barriage, Rutgers University, for The Use of Task-Centered Activities in Research with Children & Youth: Inspiration from Childhood Studies for Research in Library & Information Science

2016 - Lili Luo, San Jose State University, Allison Benedetti, UCLA, and John Jackson, Whittier College for Vignettes:  Implications for LIS Research

2015 - Leslie Thomson, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill for Surveying and Situating the Guided Tour in Library and Information Science

2014 - Angela Pollack, Western University, for Visual Methods Primer: Complimentary and Alternative Sources of Data in LIS Research

2013 - Beth St. Jean, University of Maryland - College Park, for Devising and Implementing a card-sorting technique for a longitudinal investigation of the information behavior of people with Type 2 Diabetes

2012 - Mahria Lebow and Heath L. O'Brien, University of British Columbia, for Is There a Role for Physiological Methods in the Evaluation of Human-Information Interaction?

2011 - John M. Budd, University of Missouri - Columbia, for Phenomenological Critical Realism: A Practical Method for Us

2010 - Heather Archibald and Lisa M. Given, University of Alberta, for Visual Traffic Sweeps (VTS): A Research Method for Mapping User Activities in the Library Space

2009 - Derek L. Hansen, University of Maryland, for Studying Reference Encounters with the Pair Perception Comparison (PCC) Method

2008 - No award given

2007 - No award given

2006 - Jenna Hartel, University of California

2005 - No award given

2004 - No award given

2003 - No award given

2002 - Lisa M. Given and Hope A. Olson, University of Alberta

2001 - Diane H. Sonnenwald and Barbara M. Wildemuth, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

2000 - Boryung Ju, Robert Brooks, and Kathy Burnett, Florida State University, for Measuring Navigational Preference in Hypertext Systems

1999 - Yin Zhang, University of Illinois - Urbana Champaign, for Using the Internet for Survey Research: a Case Study

1998 - Cheryl Knott Malone, University of Illinois

1997 - Matthew L. Saxton, University of California - Los Angeles